Geology Section, Leicester Literary & Philosophical Society
Saturday School Symposium March 1st 2003
Vaughan College, Leicester, 9.30 – 5.00

Hominid evolution and climate

The climatic constraints on the success or failure of hominid lineages

Surely there are few more fascinating and fundamental questions as those which we humans ask ourselves about our past - What factors influenced our evolution? How did our prehistoric ancestors and other hominid species respond to the world they found themselves in? What happened in the early stages of our evolution to make the human being what it is today? Perhaps we also ask such questions about our neanderthal cousins.

Such mysteries seem to be at the core of our humanity and this symposium will address many of these questions, taking as its central theme the role of climate and climate change in hominid evolution. These aspects of hominid studies are amongst the most important and widely studied by present-day authorities, and six of the leading experts in the field have been assembled together in Leicester for this symposium jointly presented by the Geology Section of the Leicester Literary and Philosophical Society and the Lifelong Learning Department of Leicester University.

Programme

Tectonics and climate in relationship to human evolution

Dr Mark Maslin, Department of Geography, University College, London

Abstract

Water, palaeoenvironmental change  and hominid evolution in Africa

Dr Eileen O’Brien, Institute of Ecology, University of Georgia, USA

Abstract

Species diversity and climate

Professor Peter Andrews, Department of Palaeontology, Natural History Museum, London

Abstract

Neanderthals, climate and human evolution during the last Ice Age

Professor Leslie Aiello, Department of Anthropology, University College, London

Abstract

Glacial influences on human migration in tropical Asia

Dr Douglas Brandon-Jones, Richmond, Surrey

Abstract

The possible role of climatic changes in later Pleistocene human evolution and extinctions

Professor Chris Stringer, Department of Palaeontology, Natural History Museum, London

Abstract

 

 

Abstracts

Tectonics and climate in relationship to human evolution
Dr Mark Maslin
Department of Geography, University College, London

Abstract

Many believe that environmental change in Eastern Africa stimulated the evolution of early humans. The two driving forces of environmental change in this area over the last 10 million years are local tectonics and global climate change. In this talk I want to examine first the control that regional or large scale tectonics has on global climate. As much of the present climate system can be explained by past tectonics. Indeed many of the climatic transitions which have occurred since the Miocene have been tectonic in origin, though modulated by changes in the Earth's orbit around the sun. In the second part of the talk I will examine how the local tectonic changes in Eastern Africa caused major uplift and rifting. This altered the landscape of East Africa from a flat rainforest dominate area to a highly variable landscape with many different types of vegetation. Indeed the tectonic changes made East Africa much more sensitive to climate change, may be even producing an environment that varied throughout single human lifetimes. It is on this dynamic background that human evolution occurred. Hopefully along the way I can point out possible links between our evolution and the major tectonic and climate events.

 
Water, palaeoenvironmental change and hominid evolution in Africa
Dr Eileen O’Brien
Institute of Ecology, University of Georgia, USA

Abstract

Central to understanding the course of human evolution, is understanding how Africa's physiography and biota have changed since the Miocene. For the last several decades the emphasis has been on understanding the impact of global changes in temperature on Africa's biota-especially on linking Milankovitch cycles and Pleistocene ice-age cycles to paleoenvironmental changes in Africa. Indeed, orbital forcing of temperature change has even been invoked as an evolutionary mechanism. Herein I depart from tradition and focus on changes in Africa's water supply as the primary impetus for changes in Africa's climate and biota, and thus hominid paleoecology and evolution. The keypoints include: a) something other than changes in insolation drove changes in Africa's biota--except at its highest elevations and latitudes, Africa receives a 'surplus' of insolation, making changes in rainfall the major climatic factor limiting Africa's biota; b) something other than Milankovitch cycles are causing ice-age cycles since they are now documented back to the Triassic, which makes them 'normal' earth-sun phenomena and unlikely causes of rare ice-ages; c) changes in Africa's topographic relief, hydrology and location relative to Eurasia since the Miocene are more than sufficient explanations for changes in Africa's climate and biota during the course of hominid evolution; d) based on empirical analyses of present-day relationships, the primary effect of changes in the water-energy regime on Africa's biota would be changes in its distribution-the realized distribution and diversity of vegetation causing changes in the distribution and diversity of mammals due to changes in their dietary/shelter resources; and e) relationships established between climate (water-energy dynamics) and present-day changes in potential dietary resources, associated vegetation, and mammal diversity in Africa provide objective models for predicting the impact of past/future changes in climate (regardless of their cause). They are also an objective test of inferred paleo-environmental changes based on the geologic, paleontological and paleobotanic records.

 
Species diversity and climate
Professor Peter Andrews
Department of Palaeontology, The Natural History Museum, London

Abstract

Fossil mammals form the basis for many palaeoecological reconstructions of hominid sites, the reason being that fossil hominids are usually found associated with mammalian remains. Little is known, however, about how closely different mammal species correlate with environmental and climatic factors. My aim here is to analyse mammalian data to identify the criteria that relate most strongly to environmental issues. This will be done by analysing species diversity or richness in mammalian faunas, and so a secondary question is: what are the determining ecological factors influencing mammal species richness? If we can explain patterns of species diversity, we can explain some of the factors underlying ecological variation, both in the present and in the past. Species diversity varies latitudinally, with more species in the tropics, declining towards poles. This is the largest scale and most widely known pattern in ecology, and many hypotheses have been proposed to explain it, e.g. based on energy input into the environment or productivity of ecological systems. Species diversity also varies at different trophic levels, and it has geographic, topographic and historical components as well, which are superimposed on long term and short term climatic effects. All these need to be recognized and their ecological effects analysed before we can apply them to fossil faunas. With living mammal faunas, we have evidence of their inter-relationships with climate and environment and how these affect behaviour, and these factors can be tested by multiple regression to identify significant variables affecting diversity. With fossils, we have only the composition of faunas, more often than not biased by taphonomic processes, and the morphologies of those parts of the animals that have survived the fossilisation process. These can be compared with both the regression analyses of recent faunas and the morphologies of extant species so as to interpret their ecological diversity and subsequently their palaeoecology. Examples will be taken from Pliocene faunas from East Africa.

 
Neanderthals, climate and human evolution during the last Ice Age
Professor Leslie Aiello
Department of Anthropology, University College, London

Abstract

During the later part of the Late Pleistocene (~60-25ka) Neanderthals gave way to modern humans in Europe. New research shows that this was a period of many abrupt alternations between relatively warm periods and cold intervals. It has also shown that Neanderthal archaeological sites are limited to areas where the average winter wind chill was above zero degrees Fahrenheit while contemporaneous and later Aurignacian and Gravettian archaeological sites (attributed to modern humans) are found in areas of much colder climates. This suggests that modern people had developed cultural means to cope with life in areas of Europe that were simply not accessible to the Neanderthals. Growing knowledge of European climates during the last glacial together with appreciation of the thermoregulatory limits of Neanderthals and modern humans, are helping to clarify our understanding of the patterning of human occupation in ice age Europe.

 
Glacial influences on human migration in tropical Asia
Dr Douglas Brandon-Jones
Richmond, Surrey

Abstract

Homo sapiens first reached Java (Indonesia) about 100,000 years ago during the most recent interglacial. H. erectus first appeared there about 1 Ma, between major sea level recessions at 2.4 Ma and 0.8 Ma, caused by sea water freezing into the periodically expanding polar ice-caps. During these and lesser recessions, land areas increased and, notably in Pleistocene SE Asia, some islands coalesced to form temporary subcontinents. It has been presumed that this offered plants and animals, including humans, the opportunity to disperse from one former (and present) island to another. The climatological effects of such continental shelf development, however, have generally been overlooked. Existing continents tend to be driest in their heartland. Biogeographic, pollen, fossil and climatological evidence indicates that the temporary subcontinents in SE Asia and Australasia followed suit. Their mainly arid climate, inhibiting plant life, created an obstacle, rather than an aid to dispersal. During interglacials, dispersal by natural rafting between islands (impossible during glacials, when intervening straits disappeared) was evidently more frequent and significant than has been supposed. Results from research on the systematics and zoogeography of the leaf monkeys (or colobines) are employed to illustrate how climatological conditions probably profoundly influenced human migration from Africa to Asia.

 
The possible role of climatic changes in later Pleistocene human evolution and extinctions
Professor Chris Stringer
Department of Palaeontology, The Natural History Museum, London

Abstract

Problems of chronological resolution greatly restrict our ability to match the Pleistocene fossil human succession to detailed palaeoclimatic records. This talk will address two relevant research areas. The first concerns the ancient human occupation of Britain, now the focus of a specific project (AHOB). Human occupation of Britain was influenced by two main factors, palaeogeography (particularly in relation to the periodic absence of a land bridge, largely controlled by climate) and palaeoclimate (particularly influenced by conditions in the North Atlantic). The second area concerns the European extinction of the Neanderthals and their replacement by modern humans. Particularly in the latter case, if we can move beyond reliance on uncalibrated radiocarbon chronologies, we may eventually be able to correlate human demographic changes, including Neanderthal extinction, with rapid climatic fluctuations.